Have you ever been in a situation where you just have to do
whatever it cost to survive? It could be as simple as a school assignment or as
hard as surviving in the wilderness. Brain had that thought of having do
anything to survive in the hope that someone will find him. It seemed like
Brian was willing to try anything to get someone to find him, but as time went
on he started to give up hope. Brian faced many hard and scary situations. He
faced animals that were watching him or wanted to hurt him, like the bear or
the moose that went and attacked him. At that point I would have given up or
ran far away. Brian was also very resourceful. He found food all over the place
with eggs and berries. There was one time when Brian invented a bow and arrow
to catch fish. Brain had to think really hard about the bow and arrow being in
the water because you think you know where the fish was but it was in a different
place caused by the bending of the water.
At one point I thought Brain would have given up completely.
A tornado came through and
destroyed a lot of what he had, and almost killed
him. At that point and time, even thought it was a disaster, it gave Brian hope
because the tornado caused the water to move and the plane to be exposed.
There brain was able to gather more supplies
from the plane. There was one thing that I thought was really interesting in
this whole book, Brian said that he was the new Brian. The line that I thought
was so important to Brian’s new found identity was, “He was not the same. The
plane passing changed him, the disappointment cut him down and made him new. He
was not the same and would never be again like he had been. That was one of the
true things, the new things. And the other one was that he would not die, he
would not let death in again. He was new.” That sentence shows that Brain has
made a transition from old too new, and I think was a great line.
There are many great lines in this book, and many great
experiences that Brain goes through. Most experiences, we would never have to
experience. I think a great activity would be for students to find a situation
that Brain has gone through, and then write about how they would get through
that experience. Maybe it was trying to find food. What kind of food could you
find? What animals would you have to share the food with? Another great
activity is to change the location of the plane crash. What if the plane
crashed in the desert or jungle? What food would you find? What about the
shelter? This would require some research by the students, but could be fun and
interesting to see what the students come up with.
I truly thought this book was great, and kept me guessing
what would happen next. I would recommend this book to students, especially
students that are not interested in reading because this will keep them hooked.
I agree that it would be fun to ask students to describe what they would do in Brian's shoes. It would be a good problem solving exercise, and maybe help students think more deeply about what it takes to be resourceful. I also loved the way Paulsen emphasized the new Brian. I think showing kids that perspective will prepare them to look at struggle as a time for growth.
ReplyDelete