I have always loved reading. You can gain so much from
reading. You can get so invested in the characters that sometimes you might
forget they are in a book. There are some books that I never want to put down
and would pick up to read over again. But sometimes you find a book that does
not hold your interest like others.
At first I was into Wednesday Wars, but as the book went on
I wanted something else to happen. Holling at first was a character that I
wanted to see what happened next to him. He was always in these weird
situations like the play or the rats getting out of the cage. But somewhere
along the way I lost interest in Holling. I gain more interest in Mrs. Baker
and we were only given so much information on Mrs. Baker. I wanted to know her
Olympic experience, and about her husband. I also wanted to know more about
what was going on in history around Holling. They talked about the presidency
and Martin Luther King Jr., but Holling never really talked about what he
thought of everything, just what his sister thought. I also became mad at the
dad, for not helping his daughter when she ran away and then wanted to come
back home. I don’t know what I was looking for in this book, but it never came,
whatever it was. At the end of the book Holling wanted a Barometz like his
friend because it was a moment to become a man. I wanted to have a bigger
moment, something that was memorable or words that I could come to over and
over again. There were moments in this book that were great, but most of it
could be easily forgotten.
With all that said I think that it is important that
students know it is okay to not like all books. The thing that I really think
you need to emphasize is that there should be a reason not just “because I didn’t”.
I would still have my students read to book to see if there was something they
did like about the book. I also think someone who does not like the book can
provide great feedback and discussion; they could provide a different point of
view. I do have to say though that I did like they added in different parts of
history. These book leads well in to social studies. These parts of history in
the book can lead to teaching about the Vietnam War, Martin Luther King Jr. or
Kennedy. Ask the students what they might know about any parts of history they
talk about. I would even have student’s choice different historical parts from
the book, and do a report on it. You can ask “What are the most significant
events of the Vietnam War?” “What was Martin Luther King Jr. marching to
Washington for?” The questions could go on and on.
I love your point about not liking all books. Even now as I read this book, I kept thinking "What is wrong with this book? Why don't I like it?" Even now I'm not 100% sure that I hate this book, but it is one that I don't feel like I would rush to reread. I almost think this book would be a great tool to measure what students like and dislike about books. Do a comparison reading unit and help students understand why they don't like certain genres or themes.
ReplyDeleteKelcie said she loved Mrs. Baker, I again felt distant from her, how did you like this character? I feel like she was an overly harsh mother-figure to Holling, something I'm not sure he needed.
I also loved the history in the book. Every time they mentioned a historical event/person, I felt a fun ping! of recognition. Since they didn't go into detail with the history, it made me feel like I knew a secret that gave me special insight. Maybe that's why I didn't mind that there wasn't much exploration of the history.
ReplyDeleteWhen you said that you were more interested in the other characters and referenced events than Holling, I thought that made a lot of sense. So much happened in that book, and there were so many characters, it might help tie it all together if we think of Holling kind of as a window that we used to view all of the other people.
These are some great ideas for using this book to incorporate different subjects into the classroom. I too wanted to have a focus on the historical information that was mentioned in the book and have the students dive deeper into the social and historical impact of those events. I too got tired Holling. I really liked Mrs. Baker and was hoping that her husband would come home. I wish we would have gotten to know more about her and her life.
ReplyDelete